The Wolf Among Us Trophy Guide & Road Map

The Wolf Among Us
The Wolf Among Us Trophy Guide

Estimated trophy difficulty: 1/10 (personal estimate)
Offline trophies: 36 (25, 5, 5, 1)
Online trophies: 0
Approximate amount of time to platinum: 8-11 hours.
Minimum number of playthroughs: 1 + Chapter replays.
Number of missable trophies: None.
Glitched trophies: None.
Does difficulty affect trophies?: No.
Do trophies stack?: No.
Do cheat codes disable trophies?: No.

The Wolf Among Us is another episodic series from the fantastic storytellers at Telltale Games. The game is based on a comic book series called Fables; a dark take on famous fairytale characters from our childhood, who have fled from their homeland and taken refuge in our 'Mundy' world. Their community resides in secret in a neighborhood of New York City dubbed Fabletown. The Wolf Among Us is noir style mystery that follows the sheriff of Fabletown, Bigby Wolf (reformed from his old days of eating Grannies and terrorizing pigs) as he tries to get to the bottom of a gruesome series of murders. It's up to you to decide how he conducts his investigation; will he keep his cool or let the wolf in him take over? The game is full of twists and turns, with a plot thicker than curds and whey; it's guaranteed to keep you guessing until the credits roll.

Step 1 (Play the game)

All these trophies are straight-forward. All you need to do is play the game however you feel like it and you will earn the majority of the trophies just through progression. I would suggest just playing through all the episodes and once you beat the game, go back and rewind to earn the missed Fable entries, though you can go and earn them right after you finish each episode if you wish to do so.

Step 2 (Rewind)

Novice Librarian
Apprentice Librarian
Journeyman Librarian
Master Librarian
Grand Master Librarian

If you are missing any Fables after you beat the game, now is the time to collect them. To rewind to a chapter, you will want to go to the chapter that you wish to repeat for the Fable and select it. It will ask you to pick a save file. Choose an empty one and not the one you are currently playing on because it will override your current progress. For further information on the missable Fables, please check each episode trophy for the Fables.

[PST Would Like to Thank PainOfDemise and Moosh for this Road Map]

Full Moon

Earned every Trophy in every episode of The Wolf Among Us.
(26)
Obtain all the trophies in all 5 episodes and this glorious platinum will be yours.
Welcome to Fabletown

Completed Chapter 1 of Episode 1.
Story related, cannot be missed.
- Go through the dialogue options with Mr. Toad at the start of the game.
- When you get control, pick up the matches on the floor in front of you to the right and then head to the door on the right. Knock or kick open the door.
- Talk to The Woodsman and the mystery chick and go through the dialogue options.
- Get through the unavoidable altercation with The Woodsman.
- Give the mystery chick the matchbook and go through the dialogue options.
Wolf in Sheriff's Clothing

Completed Chapter 2 of Episode 1.
Story related, cannot be missed.
- Walk down the street until you’re in front of the gate of The Woodland Luxury Apartments.
- Open the gate and make your way to the apartment until you’re stopped by Beauty.
- Once inside, go to the elevator and press the button and go inside and talk to Beast when he stops you.
- From the kitchen walk around to the living room and wake up Colin on the chair and have a lengthy chat.
- After waking up from your nap, go to the door and answer the knocking.
- Talk with Snow White.
The Long Goodbye

Completed Chapter 3 of Episode 1.
Story related, cannot be missed.
- Grab the security jacket and talk with Snow White.
- Examine the mouth and remove the item. Then finish examining the rest of the head.
- Continue to investigate the area and go right.
- Examine the blood trail on the ground and then continue to head right.
- Examine the scrap of fabric on the ground.
- Walk to the gate in front of you and examine the fence post.
- Go to Snow White and use the fabric.
The Frog or the Prince?

Completed Chapter 4 of Episode 1.
Story related, cannot be missed.
- Talk with Ichabod Crane, Snow White, and Bufkin.
- Once you’re in control, go to the Magic Mirror and talk to it and go through the dialogue options it gives you.
- Walk to your right where Snow White and Bufkin is and check out the Book of Symbols on the table. Hit and check out the ring on the page.
- Go back to the mirror and check out Prince Lawrence.
- Talk to toad on the phone and then exit using the office door.
- Choose to either go to Toad’s or Lawrence’s Apartment.
Panic in the Parlours

Completed Chapter 5 of Episode 1.
Story related, cannot be missed.

Picked Toad’s Apartment
- Leave the apartment and head downstairs
- Go to the door and check out the sobbing.
- Open Mr. Toad's apartment door.
- Talk to Toad and have a look around.
- Look at the lock on the door behind you.
- Check out the broken lamp in front of you.
- Head to your left and go down the stairs. Check out the stain on the wall next to the right side of the fireplace.
- Examine the fireplace poker on the floor in front of the fireplace.
- Catch Toad in a lie by asking about his hand.
- Examine the dust ring on the table stand next to the red chair, and catch Toad in a lie about the lamp.
- Open the window and examine the marks on the sill.
- Catch Toad in another lie about not needing his keys and call him out on it.
- Check out the object in the fur and decide what to do with the letter.
- Go up to Lawrence’s apartment door and open it.
- Check out Lawrence.
- Go to your left and enter the kitchen.
- Use the sink and go back to Lawrence and give him the water.
- Examine Lawrence again and check out the gun next to him and the shell casing.
- Examine the knife next to Lawrence.
- Examine the bullet hole on the wall.
- Open the panel to your left and check out the note on the bed.
- Go left and open the closet.
- Chase after the guy and follow the command prompts. Choose the left door with the swinging number.
- Once you catch up to him, talk with him until you get knocked out.
Picked Lawrence’s Apartment
- Go up to Lawrence’s apartment door and knock, try to open, and knock again.
- With no answer, go back to the corner and check out the open window to your right.
- When inside, check out Lawrence, and examine the bullet wound.
- Pick up the gun next to Lawrence and the bullet casing.
- Examine the dagger on the floor next to Lawrence.
- Examine the bullet hole with the gun and then pull it out.
- Examine the blood stain on the carpet and then pull on the panel.
- Read the note on the bed.
- Talk with Lawrence.
- Try and stop the intruder.
- Follow the command prompts on the foot chase and choose the left door with the swinging number.
- Get through the foot chase and talk to Dee.
- When you’re back in control, walk straight to the doors.
- Open Mr. Toad's apartment door.
- Talk to Toad and have a look around.
- Look at the lock on the door behind you.
- Check out the broken lamp in front of you.
- Head to your left and go down the stairs. Check out the stain on the wall next to the right side of the fireplace.
- Examine the fireplace poker on the floor in front of the fireplace.
- Catch Toad in a lie by asking about his hand.
- Examine the dust ring on the table stand next to the red chair, and catch Toad in a lie about the lamp.
- Open the window and examine the marks on the sill.
- Catch Toad in another lie about not needing his keys and call him out on it.
- Check out the object in the fur and decide what to do with the letter.
A Light Snowfall

Completed Episode 1: "Faith"
Story related, cannot be missed.
- Get through the dialogue with Snow White in the taxi and with Holly at the bar.
- When you regain control, sit down at the bar stool next to Gren.
- Talk to Gren and the Holly until The Woodsman comes out of the bathroom.
- Talk with The Woodsman.
- Get through the unavoidable fight with Gren and choose whether to rip off his arm or not.
- Choose whether to go after Dee or The Woodsman
Novice Librarian

Unlocked all Book of Fables entries in Episode 1.
(5)
You’ll gain all but one of the Fables entries for Episode 1 through natural progression. To gain the last one you’re missing, go back to the last chapter (Chapter 6) and pick the "Rewind" option. It'll prompt you to pick a save file. Pick an empty file so you don't overwrite the choices from your initial playthrough. Go through Chapter 6 again and when faced with the choice with Gren at the end, choose the opposite from which you picked before.
Right to an Attorney

Completed Chapter 1 of Episode 2.
Story related, can't be missed.

This trophy will pop after Bigby arrives back at The Woodland Apartments with Crane.
Breaking Point

Completed Chapter 2 of Episode 2.
Story related, can't be missed.

This trophy will pop after Snow and Bigby enter Snow's office.
Sisters

Completed Chapter 3 of Episode 2.
Story related, can't be missed.

This trophy will pop after Bigby leaves the Trip Trap bar.
Made Them Cry

Completed Chapter 4 of Episode 2.
Story related, can't be missed.

This trophy will pop after Nerissa hands Bigby the hotel room key and he leaves The Pudding and Pie.
Can I Get a Fresh Set of Towels?

Completed Chapter 5 of Episode 2.
Story related, can't be missed.

This trophy will pop after Beauty takes Bigby up the stairs in the Open Arms hotel.
No Respect for the Dead

Completed Episode 2: "Smoke and Mirrors"
Story related, can't be missed.

This trophy will pop once Bigby has finished searching room 207.
Apprentice Librarian

Unlocked all Book of Fables entries in Episode 2.
(18)
There are 11 Book of Fables entries in Episode 2, most of these will be found naturally throughout the story. Below is a list of all the entries and where they can be found in each chapter. Pay particular attention to #4 in Chapter 3 as it is missable. You will also need to rewind Chapter 2 to complete either #1 or #2, depending on the choices you made during your original playthrough.

A small note for unlocking fables in Chapter 3. Fable #4 event happens before #3. So when you get #4 before #3, you didn't miss it, it just happens later in the story.

Chapter 2

#1 Ichabod's Denial: Beat up the suspect during the interrogation

#2 Bluebeard's Mercy: Don't beat up the suspect during the interrogation

Chapter 3

#3 The Witches and Wizards of the Thirteenth Floor: Snow mentions them when talking about glamours whilst investigating the body

#4 The Magic Mirror: Tell Snow 'In a minute' after talking to TJ, then talk to the Magic Mirror

#5 The Witching Well: Look at the Witching Well (also unlocks as you walk passed it)

#6 Jack Horner: Meet Jack Horner

#7 Lily: Talk to Holly about her sister

#8 Troll cross: Talk to Holly about her sister's brooch (make sure to pick it up when examining the body)

Chapter 4

#9 Georgie Porgie - After Bigby makes an appointment with Nerissa

#10 Clever Hans - After Bigby makes an appointment with Nerissa

#11 Nerissa - After Bigby makes an appointment with Nerissa
Promising Leads

Completed Chapter 1 of Episode 3.
Story related, cannot be missed.
- Go through the dialogue options with Beauty and Beast.
Belly Full of Stones

Completed Chapter 2 of Episode 3.
Story related, cannot be missed.
- Walk up to where Snow is speaking and don't interrupt her.
- Go to the left and check out the notes on the table. It will give you Troll Funeral Rites.
- Talk to Snow and Holly and go through all the dialogue with everyone at the funeral site.
What Big Eyes You Have

Completed Chapter 3 of Episode 3.
Story related, cannot be missed.
- Go through the dialogue options with Snow
- Walk over to Crane's desk and search it. Open up the drawer in the middle and examine the book.
- Go through the dialogue options with Snow and Bluebeard.
- Go to Crane's apartment first.
Huff and Puff

Completed Chapter 4 of Episode 3.
Story related, cannot be missed.
- Go up the hall and enter Crain's apartment.
- Go into the room where the phone and answering machine is located and examine the statue on the desk. This will give you the Headless Horseman.
- While at the desk, examine the drawer and look at the envelope. When finished, take the key underneath.
- Go to Crane's bedroom door and use the key to enter and confront Jack.
- Go to the Twins place and talk to Flycatcher. This will give you the fable for him. Next you will head to the bar.
- Talk with Gren and the Woodsman
- When in Holly's room, examine the cot twice and when she moves her hand, grab the box.
- Examine the photo in the box, then the book while talking to Holly in between.
Severe Case of Lycanthropy

Completed Chapter 5 of Episode 3.
Story related, cannot be missed.
- Choose how you want to enter Aunty Greenleaf's apartment.
- When you get into the apartment, examine the tree in the room, the partition, and the closet door.
- Talk with Snow and Aunty Greenleaf and decide whether to burn the tree or not. You will get Glamour Tube for sparing it, and Glamour Tree for burning it.
The Enchanted Land of New York City

Completed Episode 3: "A Crooked Mile"
Story related, cannot be missed.
- Go through the dialogue options until you confront Crane.
- Talk with Bloody Mary and the Twins.
- Make your final choice on whether to spare or kill Dee.
Journeyman Librarian

Unlocked all Book of Fables entries in Episode 3.
(13)
You should have gathered all but one fable if you followed the guide or if you visited certain areas in an specific order. If you are missing one, then you'll need to rewind Chapter 5 and make the opposite choice at the end of the chapter.

If you're missing more than one, here is a list of all the missable fables and how to obtain them:
- Troll Funeral Rites: Chapter 2 - Do not interrupt Snow's speech. Go to the table on the left and view the cards.
- Headless Horseman: Chapter 4 - Crane's apartment on top of his desk. View the statue. It's best to visit here first, just not last. If you go their second, make sure you tell Bluebeard you're heading their first.
- Flycatcher: Chapter 4 - At Dee and Dum's Office, you'll talk to Flycatcher. It's best to visit this place second, just not last.
- Glamour Tube: Chapter 5 - Spare Aunty Greenleaf's tree.
- Glamour Tree: Chapter 5 - Burn Aunty Greenleaf's tree.
Once Upon a Time

Completed Chapter 1 of Episode 4.
Story related, can't be missed.
- Talk to Doctor Swineheart and set Bigby's arm
- Go through all conversation options with Snow and Colin
- Go through all conversation options with Nerissa
- Go through all conversation options with Snow
There Was a Wolf

Completed Chapter 2 of Episode 4.
Story related, can't be missed.
- Go through all conversation options with Snow
- Walk to Beauty and Beast's Apartment and knock
- Once you're in, look around then knock on the door when you're ready
- Go through all conversation options with Beauty and Beast
- Choose to go to the Lucky Pawn first (to get a Book of Fables entry)
Who Ruled The Land

Completed Chapter 3 of Episode 4.
Story related, can't be missed.
- Go through all conversation options with Toad and Jack
- Investigate the objects in the Lucky Pawn, particularly the Pin Cushion
- Go through all conversation options with Jack and Jersey
- Either restrain Woody or Jersey
- Complete the fight sequence
- Go through all conversation options with Jersey and Woodsman
He Was Much Feared

Completed Chapter 4 of Episode 4.
Story related, can't be missed.
- Decide whether to keep smoking or stop smoking
- Look around The Cut Above
- Go through the conversation options with Johann
- Open the counter door
- Go through the conversation options with Johann
- Open the door
- Talk to Johann
- Look at everything around the lab
- Examine the coat pockets
- Go through the conversation options with Johann
But Soon He Mended His Evil Ways

Completed Chapter 5 of Episode 4.
Story related, can't be missed.
- Go through the conversation options with Snow, Bluebeard and Toad
- Go through the options with the Magic Mirror
- Talk to Snow
And All Were Happy

Completed Episode 4: "In Sheep's Clothing"
(1)
Story related, can't be missed.
- Open the door and walk forward into the light
- Go through the conversation options with Tiny Tim
- Talk to the Crooked Man
Master Librarian

Unlocked all Book of Fables entries in Episode 4.
(12)
All but one of the Book of Fables entries can be unlocked by playing the game however you wish. below is a list of all the entries and where they unlocked for me. The missable entry is in bold:
- Silver Bullets - Chapter 1 - Unlocked whilst Dr Swineheart is patching Bigby up
- Acting Deputy - Chapter 1 - Unlocked whilst Snow is discussing what to do about the Crooked Man
- Life on the Farm - Chapter 1 - Unlocked when Snow threatens to send Colin back to the farm
- Donkeyskin coat - Chapter 3 - Unlocked when Bigby sees Toad trying to pawn the coat to Jack
- Briar Rose - Chapter 3 - Unlocked when Bigby looks at the pin cushion in the Lucky Pawn, YOU MUST VISIT THE LUCKY PAWN BEFORE THE CUT ABOVE TO UNLOCK THIS.
- Jersey Devil - Chapter 3 - Unlocked when the Woodsman attacks Jersey
- Woodsman's Axe - Chapter 3 - Unlocked once Woody gets his axe back after the fight with Jersey
- Johann - Chapter 4 - Unlocked once Bigby is done investigating The Cut Above
- Bluebeard's Money - Chapter 5 - Unlocked in the business offices when Toad and Bluebeard are arguing
- The Crooked Lair - Chapter 6 - Unlocked when Tiny Tim shows you into the Crooked Man's office
- The Crooked Man - Chapter 6 - Unlocked when Tiny Tim shows you into the Crooked Man's office
- Tiny Tim - Chapter 6 - Unlocked when Tiny Tim shows you into the Crooked Man's
Beginning of the End

Completed Chapter 1 of Episode 5.
Story related, cannot be missed.
- Go through the conversation options with the Crooked Man and get through the altercation.
This House of Straw

Completed Chapter 2 of Episode 5.
Story related, cannot be missed.
- Get through the chase QTE event and when you jump off the interstate, you can choose to land on the limo (Crooked Man) or the car (Georgie).
- Another QTE event will take place. if you jump on Georgie's car. After, you'll reach Georgie's Place. If you jumped on the Limo, you'll be knocked unconscious. You'll eventually wake up and go to Georgie's place.
A Silver Bullet

Completed Chapter 3 of Episode 5.
(2)
Story related, cannot be missed.
- Enter Georgie's place, go down the hallway and talk with him (if you jumped on the car, Vivian will be alive still.)
- Decide to kill or leave Georgie to suffer.
- When you arrive at the Sheppard Metalworks, enter through the main door and continue through the big metal double door into the main part of the facility.
- Take a left and go straight past the board with the pictures and across the walkway and you'll end up in a room with a workbench. Examine the bench to view the silver bullets.
- When you confront Bloody Mary, make sure when the dialogue option comes about, pick "Hey, I'm talking to you" to get Bloody Mary to mention your mother to unlock a Fable.
- Search for Bloody Mary and complete the QTE event with her to finish your epic battle.
My Last Cigarette

Completed Chapter 4 of Episode 5.
Story related, cannot be missed.
- Talk with the Crooked Man.
- Decide to kill or spare the Crooked Man.
The North Wind Blows

Completed Chapter 5 of Episode 5.
Story related, cannot be missed.

Crooked Man Spared
- Talk with Snow White and the community to discuss what is to be done with Crooked Man.
- Decide on whether to kill, lock up, or throw the Crooked Man down the well.
- After the small altercation, decide whether to kill, lock up, or throw the Crooked Man down the well again.
Crooked Man Killed
- Talk with Snow White and the community to discuss about what you've done to the Crooked Man and past events.
Happily Ever After

Completed Episode 5: "Cry Wolf"
Story related, cannot be missed.
- Back at the Woodland Apartment complex, go through the small conversation with Snow White.
- Go through the dialogue options with Toad and TJ.
- Go through the dialogue options with Nerissa.
- Pick to go after Nerissa or leave her alone.
Grand Master Librarian

Unlocked all Book of Fables entries in Episode 5.
(5)
After completing Episode 5, you might not have any fables missing depending on your dialogue choices in Chapter 3. If you do, you'll want to rewind to Chapter 3 to get it the one you missed.

The only Fable you should be missing, if you are missing any, is the third one. In order to get this, when you confront Mary in the Sheppard Metalworks facility, there should be a dialogue option "I'm talking to you". You must pick that in order for her to mention Bigby's mother and get the "Winter Wolf" Fable entry.