Fibbage 3: Crowd Teaser Trophy in The Jackbox Party Pack 4

This can be earned in the same game as Fibbage 3: Doubly Impressive. You need to start a game with a minimum of 2 Players and have 1 Audience member join (have another person join the room after the game has started). The Audience member will get to choose a lie to be added to the answers to choose from. Any player needs to choose that lie as their answer. The trophy unlocks when the winner of the round is announced.