This trophy has a few steps involved. You need all four characters to make it to The Old Warehouse. While Jayden is fighting the Origami Killer, don't push any buttons. Let him be killed. While Madison is trying to convince Blake that Ethan is innocent, let her get arrested. After rescuing Shaun, resuscitate him and carry him out. Have Ethan put him down before opening the door. Doing those three things will earn you this trophy (and a few new endings, so make sure you're saving if you're doing this on Chapter Select).
Replay Chapter: The Old Warehouse